Skip to content
Shopify

Hosted Checkout Fees for Stores Doing $1M+ a Year: What You Actually Pay

A store doing $1M a year pays $25,500–$39,800 just to take payments. The full fee stack by provider, the plan break-evens, and when to negotiate.

By Lynxwell Digital November 9, 2026 12 min read
Hosted Checkout Fees for Stores Doing $1M+ a Year: What You Actually Pay

A store doing $1M a year in online sales pays roughly $30,000 to $40,000 a year just to take payments on a hosted checkout — 2.5% to 3.5% of sales, plus the platform subscription. The gap between the cheapest and the most expensive common setup at the same volume is about $9,000 a year, and most of it hides in four places the pricing pages never put next to each other: the plan tier, the platform's cut on outside gateways, international surcharges, and the fees that survive a refund.

"Hosted checkout" means the payment page lives on the provider's domain, not yours: Shopify Checkout, Stripe Checkout, PayPal Checkout, Square Online Checkout, and BigCommerce's checkout. You rent the page, and the rent is four separate lines: the platform subscription, the card processing rate, the platform's cut if you use someone else's gateway, and the add-ons. Compare any one line on its own and you will pick wrong.

What $1M a year actually costs, provider by provider

All figures below are my own arithmetic from the vendors' list prices, read from their own pricing pages on 9 November 2026: $1M in annual sales, $100 average order (10,000 orders), annual billing wherever a discount applies. Your numbers move with your average order — the 30¢ per-order fee is 0.3% at $100 and 0.6% at $50 — but the ranking holds.

SetupSubscription / yrProcessing / yrTotal / yrEffective rate
Shopify Grow + Shopify Payments$948$30,000$30,9483.09%
Shopify Basic + Shopify Payments$348$32,000$32,3483.23%
Stripe Checkout (custom store)$0$32,000$32,0003.20%
Shopify Advanced + Shopify Payments$3,588$28,000$31,5883.16%
Square Online Checkout (Plus plan)$588$32,000$32,5883.26%
BigCommerce Scale + Braintree$8,088$31,800$39,8883.99%
PayPal Checkout (wallet payments)$0$39,800$39,8003.98%
Shopify Plus + Shopify Payments$27,600$25,500$53,1005.31%

The rates behind the table, all from the vendors' own pages: Shopify Payments charges 2.9% + 30¢ on Basic, 2.7% on Grow, 2.5% on Advanced and 2.25% on Plus, with plans at $39, $105 and $399 a month ($29, $79 and $299 on annual billing) and Plus from $2,300 a month. Stripe's standard rate is 2.9% + 30¢ for domestic cards, with no monthly fee, and Stripe Checkout itself is included. PayPal Checkout runs 3.49% + 49¢ for wallet payments; cards through PayPal Checkout cost 2.99% + 49¢, which works out to $34,800 at this volume. BigCommerce's Scale plan is $399 a month ($299 on annual billing), and its PayPal Braintree processing starts at 2.89% + 29¢.

Two rows in that table need explaining, because they are where stores get surprised. BigCommerce Scale carries a 0.9% overage on monthly GMV above $33,333 — at $1M a year that is about $4,500 a year on top of the plan, which is why its subscription line reads $8,088, not $3,588. (BigCommerce counts GMV after a 10% reduction, so $1M of sales is $900,000 of GMV — that is why the overage is $4,500, not $5,400. BigCommerce's pricing page states the 10% reduction and the 0.9% rate.) And Shopify Plus looks absurd at 5.31% effective because the $27,600 platform fee dwarfs the processing saving. Plus is not a fee play at $1M. It is a features buy — checkout customization, B2B, expansion stores — and the fee math only starts to favour it near $10M a year, as the next section shows.

The three break-evens nobody runs

The plan decision is arithmetic, not loyalty. Three break-evens, all from the list prices above:

Grow beats Basic above $300,000 a year. Grow costs $600 a year more in subscription ($948 vs $348) and saves 0.2% on every sale. At $1M that is $2,000 saved against $600 spent — Grow wins by $1,400. Below $300,000, Basic is cheaper.

Advanced beats Grow only above $1,320,000 a year. Advanced costs $2,640 a year more than Grow and saves the same 0.2%. At $1M a year, Advanced is $640 a year more expensive than Grow. Stores upgrade to Advanced for the rate and lose money on the rate until they pass $1.32M. Buy Advanced for its features — third-party calculated shipping, more staff accounts, Markets controls — not for the processing discount.

Plus beats Advanced only above roughly $9,600,000 a year. Plus costs $24,012 a year more in subscription and saves 0.25% on processing. At $1M, Plus costs about $21,500 a year more than Advanced in total. Above roughly $800,000 a month, the flat $2,300-a-month fee gives way to a variable platform fee — partner guides put it at 0.25% to 0.40% of monthly sales, reportedly capped around $40,000 a month — but Shopify does not publish the rate, so treat any single percentage as a starting point and confirm it with Shopify sales. At $1M a year you are far below that threshold, so the flat fee is what you pay.

The platform cut: the fee for not using their processor

This is the line most stores miss entirely. If you use a payment provider other than the platform's own, the platform charges its own percentage on top of the gateway's rate. Shopify adds 2% on Basic, 1% on Grow, 0.6% on Advanced and 0.2% on Plus. A $100 order paid through your own Stripe account on Basic costs $3.20 to Stripe plus $2.00 to Shopify — $5.20 against $3.20 on Shopify Payments. At $1M a year, that is $20,000 for the privilege of using your own gateway.

BigCommerce works the other way round, with one new asterisk. Orders through an embedded provider — Stripe, PayPal Braintree, Adyen and the rest of its approved list — carry no platform fee. But since its June 2026 pricing change, orders through a provider outside that list pay an Open Payment Provider fee: 2% on Core, 1% on Growth and 0.6% on Scale, per BigCommerce's 2026 plan update. The "no transaction fees" line BigCommerce used for a decade now needs checking against which gateway you actually use.

Four add-ons that move the real number

International cards. Shopify adds 1% on international cards. Stripe adds 1.5%, plus another 1% if currency conversion is needed. PayPal adds 1.5% for international transactions, plus a 3% to 4% currency conversion spread. If 20% of your sales are international — $200,000 — that is $2,000 extra on Shopify, $5,000 on Stripe, and up to $8,000 on PayPal's conversion spread alone. The spread, not the headline rate, is what makes PayPal expensive abroad.

Premium cards. Shopify charges more for premium cards: 3.5% + 30¢ on Basic, falling to 2.95% on Plus, against 2.9% for a standard card. If a meaningful share of your customers pay with Amex or corporate cards, your effective rate sits above the table above, and the gap widens on the cheaper plans.

Refunds. Nobody returns the fee. Shopify's Help Center states it plainly: "the original credit card transaction fee isn't refunded to you when issuing a refund." PayPal's fee page says the same: "the fees you originally paid to receive the payment are not returned to you." At a 10% refund rate on $1M, that is roughly $3,000 a year in fees paid on sales that did not happen. It is not a line you can negotiate away; it is a reason to keep the refund rate down.

Chargebacks and subscriptions. Stripe charges $15 for every dispute you receive. PayPal charges a $20 chargeback fee, a $15 standard dispute fee, and a $30 high-volume dispute fee. And if you run subscriptions, Stripe Billing adds 0.7% of billing volume — $7,000 a year on $1M of subscription revenue, on top of the processing rate.

What merchants at this volume actually do

The pricing pages tell you the list. The forums tell you what happens when stores try to move it.

You cannot negotiate Shopify Payments rates — below Plus, the lever is the plan. In Shopify's own community forum, staff answer the question directly: the rates on the pricing page are non-negotiable, and "the only way for you to reduce the credit card fees you pay when accepting payments through Shopify Payments is by upgrading your subscription to a higher plan." One merchant in that thread had Square at around 2.1% against Shopify Advanced's 2.5% — but routing Square through Shopify adds the 0.6% surcharge, so the "cheaper" gateway costs more than staying put. That is the trap in a nutshell: a lower gateway rate that triggers the platform cut is not lower.

Stripe does negotiate — once you are big enough to be worth a call. Stripe's own pricing page offers custom packages for large volume, including interchange-plus pricing and volume discounts. What that is worth in practice: a payments consultancy reports negotiated Stripe deals including a blended 2.40% + 20¢, an interchange-plus deal at 0.22% + 15¢ over interchange, and a best case of 0.09% + 8¢ for a merchant processing over $4M a month (Merchant Cost Consulting). The threshold where Stripe starts talking is reported at around $50,000 a month in volume (Fincoro). At $1M a year — about $83,000 a month — you are in the room. Go in with two competing quotes and your effective rate worked out, not with a request for "a better rate."

PayPal has an interchange-plus product most stores never see. PayPal's own fee page lists Advanced Credit and Debit Card Payments at "Interchange Pass-through Costs + 0.49% + fixed fee." The default is the flat 2.99% or 3.49%; the interchange-plus route exists for established high-volume businesses, and you have to ask for it.

And the rate is the wrong number to optimize first. Shopify claims Shop Pay converts up to 50% better than guest checkout. The documented reality is smaller: in Shopify's own Princess Polly case study, the measured lift was closer to 1% to 4% storewide (CleanCommit's read of the case study). Even 1% more conversion on $1M is $10,000 of revenue — more than three times what a 0.3% rate cut saves. A checkout that costs slightly more per order and converts slightly better wins, every time. That is why our checkout conversion fixes come before any rate negotiation in the order below — and why the Shopify checkout customization guide matters even though Plus is not a fee saving.

What we'd do

At Lynxwell Digital, this is the order we'd work through it in for a store doing around $1M a year:

1. Work out your effective rate first. Total fees paid last year divided by total volume. If it is above 3.2% on mostly domestic sales, something is wrong — usually an outside gateway triggering the platform cut, or a large PayPal share at wallet rates. 2. If you are on Shopify, use Shopify Payments and sit on Grow. At $1M it is the cheapest total in the table, and Advanced only pays above $1.32M. Do not buy Plus for the rate; buy it when a named feature needs it. 3. If you run Stripe on a custom store, ask for interchange-plus. You are past the volume threshold. Bring competing quotes and your effective rate, and get whatever they offer in writing. 4. Offer PayPal as an option, never as the only checkout. At 3.49% + 49¢ for wallet payments it is the most expensive way to take money from a customer who would happily have paid by card — and its 3% to 4% conversion spread is the worst of the group abroad. 5. Fix conversion before renegotiating. Shop Pay on, one-page checkout, and the conversion fixes in our checkout guide — a single point of conversion is worth three times a 0.3% rate cut at this volume. Our Stripe vs PayPal vs Square fee guide has the same math at smaller volumes if you are still growing toward $1M. 6. Then re-check yearly. Interchange changes twice a year, platforms reprice, and the plan that was cheapest at $600,000 is not the plan that is cheapest at $1.5M. The break-evens above are the test — rerun them, don't trust last year's answer.

If your checkout bill doesn't match the math above — or you can't tell what your effective rate is from your statements — send us your store URL and we'll audit it: what you're actually paying per order, which plan is cheapest at your volume, and how much of the bill is international and refund leakage. We build and fix Shopify stores at Lynxwell Digital, and the audit tells you the truth before you spend anything. Shopify checkout work like this starts from $450 — see pricing.

FAQ

How much does hosted checkout cost at $1M a year?

Between about $30,900 and $39,900 a year in total — subscription plus processing — for the common setups at $100 average order. Shopify Grow with Shopify Payments is the cheapest in our comparison at $30,948; PayPal Checkout on wallet payments is the most expensive at $39,800. Shopify Plus costs $53,100 in total at this volume because the $27,600 platform fee outweighs its lower card rate.

Is Shopify Plus cheaper on fees at $1M a year?

No. Plus costs about $21,500 a year more than Advanced in total at $1M, because its $2,300-a-month subscription saves only 0.25% on processing. The fee math only favours Plus above roughly $9.6M a year. Buy Plus for checkout customization, B2B and expansion stores — not for the rate.

Can you negotiate Shopify Payments rates?

Not below Plus. Shopify's own community forum states the published rates are non-negotiable and the only way to lower them is upgrading to a higher plan. On Plus, card rates are negotiated. On Stripe, PayPal and other processors, interchange-plus pricing opens up once you process roughly $50,000 a month or more.

Is Stripe cheaper than Shopify Payments?

At list price they are identical: 2.9% + 30¢ for a domestic card. Stripe becomes cheaper when you negotiate interchange-plus pricing at volume, or when you run it on a custom store with no platform cut. On Shopify, running your own Stripe account costs more, because Shopify adds its 2%, 1%, 0.6% or 0.2% third-party transaction fee on top of Stripe's rate.

What is the cheapest hosted checkout at $1M a year?

In this comparison, Shopify Grow with Shopify Payments: $948 a year in subscription plus $30,000 in processing, $30,948 in total at $100 average order. The ranking changes with your average order, your international share and your refund rate — a store with mostly $30 orders or 40% international sales should rerun the table with its own numbers before choosing.

Not sure what’s quietly broken on your store? Send us the URL and we’ll email the top three issues we can see from outside, free, within one US business day. The full Store Leak Audit is $290: lynxwelldigital.com/lp/store-leak-audit

#Shopify#payment processing#checkout fees#ecommerce costs
All posts

Something on your store quietly broken?

Send your store URL and we'll email the top three issues we can see from outside, free, within one US business day. If you want the full list, the Store Leak Audit is $290.

First call's free
5.0 · usually replies in ~2 hours
  • Real human replies in ~2 hours
  • Fixed price, agreed before you pay
  • No lock-in, you own everything
  • Free first call + honest audit